Question Wrong in Daily Challenge

Asked by Anonymous on 2026-11-20 in CAT Prep

Second Point

Five handloom clusters (Chanderi, Kanchipuram, Pochampally, Maheshwar and Bhagalpur) sent saree bales to three trade expos last season, in Delhi, Kolkata and Chennai. Each cluster attended at least one expo and sent the same number of bales to every expo it attended; that number is the cluster's consignment. The five consignments were 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 bales in some order. A cluster's total dispatch is its consignment multiplied by the number of expos it attended. An expo received exactly the consignments of the clusters that attended it.

Bales received: Delhi 9, Kolkata 10. Chennai's figure is not given.

Also known:
1. No two clusters attended exactly the same set of expos.
2. Each expo was attended by exactly three of the five clusters.
3. Chennai received more bales than Kanchipuram's total dispatch.
4. Bhagalpur attended the Delhi expo.
5. Kanchipuram attended every expo that Maheshwar attended (and possibly others).
6. Pochampally's total dispatch was greater than Chanderi's.
7. Chanderi's consignment was greater than Bhagalpur's.

1 Answer

PRIYANSHIII 🌻 · 2026-11-20 · 1 helpful

I checked the question, especially Point 2. Let me explain why it is logically correct.
**Point 2 states:*
"Each expo was attended by exactly three of the five clusters."
Iska simple meaning hai:
- Total 5 clusters hain.
- Delhi, Kolkata aur Chennai – har expo mein exactly 3 clusters ne participate kiya.
- Therefore, har expo mein exactly 2 clusters absent rahe.
So, this condition is clear and does not create any ambiguity.
**Now, let's understand the calculation used in the solution.**
The five consignments are 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5.
Total consignments:
1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 = 15 bales.
Since each expo received consignments from exactly 3 clusters, we can calculate the absent clusters' consignments by subtracting the expo's received bales from 15.
**For Delhi:**
Total bales received = 9
15 − 9 = 6
Therefore, the two absent clusters must have consignments adding up to 6.
Possible pairs:
- 1 + 5 = 6
- 2 + 4 = 6
**For Kolkata:**
Total bales received = 10
15 − 10 = 5
Therefore, the two absent clusters must have consignments adding up to 5.
Possible pairs:
- 1 + 4 = 5
- 2 + 3 = 5
This is how Point 2 helps us determine the possible attendance combinations.
Conclusion:
Point 2 is mathematically valid and consistent with the given information. It simply establishes that exactly two clusters are absent from every expo.
The calculation of 15 − 9 and 15 − 10 is also correct.
However, there is a difference between saying that Point 2 is correct and saying that the entire question and its final answer are correct. The 14 possible outcomes and the answer keys should be independently verified before declaring the complete question error-free.
If there is a specific objection to Point 2, please share it so we can examine it logically.

Open this discussion on Percentyl Community →